What Is a Motion to Vacate?
A motion to vacate judgment asks the court to set aside (cancel) a judgment that was previously entered. In debt collection cases, this almost always involves a default judgment -- a judgment entered because you did not respond to the lawsuit. Vacating the judgment reopens the case and gives you the chance to defend yourself.
The legal authority varies by state, but in federal court it is Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b). Most states have similar rules. The motion must typically be filed within a reasonable time, and for certain grounds, within one year of the judgment.
Grounds for Vacating a Judgment
Excusable neglect (Rule 60(b)(1)): You had a legitimate reason for not responding -- illness, emergency, military deployment, or you genuinely did not understand you needed to respond. Newly discovered evidence (60(b)(2)): Evidence showing you don't owe the debt or the amount is wrong. Fraud or misrepresentation (60(b)(3)): The creditor lied to the court. The judgment is void (60(b)(4)): The court lacked jurisdiction or you were never properly served. Satisfaction (60(b)(5)): The debt has already been paid. Any other reason justifying relief (60(b)(6)): A catch-all for extraordinary circumstances.
Improper Service -- Your Strongest Argument
If you were never properly served with the lawsuit, the default judgment is void and must be vacated. This is the strongest possible ground because a void judgment can be challenged at any time -- there is no statute of limitations. Common service defects: papers left at the wrong address, "sewer service" (process server lied), service on someone who does not live with you, or no service at all.
To prove improper service: obtain the proof of service from the court file, check whether the person described matches your description, check whether you were actually at the address on the date claimed, and gather evidence (travel records, work records, witnesses) showing you were not served.
How to File the Motion
Step 1: Obtain a copy of the judgment and entire court file. Step 2: Identify your grounds (service defect, excusable neglect, fraud, etc.). Step 3: Draft the motion with a supporting declaration or affidavit. Step 4: File it with the court that entered the judgment. Step 5: Serve a copy on the creditor's attorney. Step 6: Attend the hearing.
You should also prepare a proposed answer to the underlying lawsuit. Courts want to see that vacating the judgment will lead to a real defense, not just delay. If you have a meritorious defense (statute of limitations, wrong amount, wrong person), include it in your motion.
Meritorious Defense Requirement
Most courts require you to show a "meritorious defense" -- a valid reason you could win if the case were reopened. This does not mean you must prove you will win, just that you have a plausible defense. Examples: the statute of limitations has expired, the amount is wrong, the debt was already paid, you are not the right person, the debt was already discharged in bankruptcy, or the creditor cannot prove they own the debt.
What If the Motion Is Denied?
If the court denies your motion to vacate, you can: appeal the denial (usually within 30 days), file a motion for reconsideration with additional evidence, or turn to bankruptcy. Bankruptcy's automatic stay immediately stops enforcement of the judgment, and if the underlying debt is dischargeable, the judgment becomes permanently unenforceable after discharge.
Even with a judgment in place, you may be judgment proof -- meaning the creditor cannot collect despite having the judgment. This buys time while you explore options.
Judgment Liens and Your Property
A judgment often creates a lien on your real property. Even if you vacate the judgment or discharge the debt in bankruptcy, you may need to separately remove the judgment lien. In bankruptcy, 11 U.S.C. 522(f) allows you to avoid judgment liens that impair your homestead exemption. Outside bankruptcy, you may need a release from the creditor or a court order.
Check your county recorder's office to see if a judgment lien has been filed against your property. If it has, address it directly -- it will not disappear on its own, even after the judgment is vacated.
Explore All Topics
Grounds for Vacating a Judgment -- Legal bases under Rule 60(b)
Motion to Vacate Template -- Step-by-step filing guide
Time Limits by State -- State-by-state deadline guide
Improper Service -- Challenging sewer service and defective process
Excusable Neglect -- When failing to respond is not your fault
Meritorious Defense -- Showing you can win if the case reopens
After Vacating -- What happens next
Default vs. Consent Judgments -- Key differences
Appeal vs. Motion to Vacate -- Which should you file?
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to vacate a default judgment?
It varies by state and grounds. For excusable neglect, typically within one year. For void judgments (improper service), there is generally no time limit. For fraud, usually within a reasonable time but check your state's rules. Act as quickly as possible -- delay weakens your case.
Can I vacate a judgment from years ago?
Possibly, especially if you were never properly served. A void judgment (due to lack of jurisdiction or improper service) can be challenged at any time. Other grounds may be time-barred. Consult a consumer protection attorney about your specific situation.
Do I need a lawyer to vacate a judgment?
You can file pro se (without a lawyer), but the motion must follow court rules for formatting, service, and legal arguments. Legal aid organizations can help, and some consumer protection attorneys take these cases on contingency if there are FDCPA violations involved.
Check your bankruptcy discharge eligibility with our free screening tool.
Free Discharge Screener